Hi folks,
I'm glad to have found an independent voice in this thread about Google. Below I provide my comments about recent experience with the Google, Incorporated Company.
Last night I tried to provide my comments on Matt Cutts blog (Matt Cutts is a high figure at Google, a head of Google anti-spam team and... Google Public Relations guy at the same time). The post that drawn my attention was about Google Chrome:
My five months with Google Chrome, a new "KOOL" (as they call it in the Google Plex) web browser.
The reason I posted it was simple - Matt's post seemed to me like a blatant advertising copy and only showed the positive aspects of Chrome (of course). I noticed some "negativish" comments of other users so I thought I'd post my true and unbiased opinion as well.
Near the comment box there was a message that "I pre-moderate first-time commenters. Please review my comment policy before leaving a comment." Fair enough, that made sense.
Here was my comment about Google Chrome:
Old habits die hard.
I'm not switching to Chrome. It has no advantage (other than speed maybe, but with broadband access that's hardly an issue) over other browser, especially Firefox. New design and getting used to layout, buttons, etc. doesn't help either.
It would have to be WOW for me and I suppose for millions of other users to make a switch. But that's not even close to it.See a screen shot attached as a proof.
A couple of hours after posting the comment, I went back to the page and could see my post correctly so that (listen to this part) - it appeared my comment was published and live on the website. I could also see subsequent posts made by other users. Good, I thought to myself, maybe Matt agrees with me, the end user of their product. Even if not, maybe other users will find my unbiased comment useful.
But then I went to check something using another browser (I posted my comment using Firefox). I opened IE and went to the same page I posted my comment. Ooppss -- I realized my comment was not there! Now I got the trick Matt and his team uses (let's call it "Google glass ceiling policy"). I was duped my comment was live and available to thousands of users, but in fact
it was only my assumption. The fact is, my comment was offline and visible only on my computer and on this particular browser I posted from (I guess they used some kind of cookie to save my post).
I just wonder how many hundreds or thousands of users have actually bothered to post something at mattcutts.com and were duped into believing that their post is live??? Without any notification about the fact that the message appeared to be live but in fact it was not! I feel for them as I feel for all those people who cannot express their true opinion about Google and their "glass ceiling" policies.
I checked the "
comment policy" again and all I could find:
"
I reserve the right to delete comments for any reason, but I try to allow on-topic, constructive comments."
I believe my comment was on topic and constructive. Hmm, but "
delete comments for any reason" -- there you go! The "Google glass ceiling" policy has come into play again.
Folks, my advice to you (especially the young ones) is - go and study hard, read a lot of useful/academic books, don't use any "gadgets" that dumb you down, and train your brains so that you can still catch the tricks Google is trying to impose on you and on your family. Otherwise, you will get yet another Google victim on the road without even realizing that.